eLWIS Has Left the Building – Goodbye to Customization of ERP Systems
You are here:Home»eLWIS Has Left the Building – Goodbye to Customization of ERP Sy...
If you are in the ERP-industry, you have undoubtedly heard about how German retailer Lidl have stopped and written off €500M on a 7-year attempt to customise SAP to support their business processes. (The project carried the name eLWIS – elektronische Lidl WarenwirtschaftsInformationsSystem – pronounced “Elvis” in German.)
While only very few companies can survive a €500M write-off, the incident is an excellent example of what most SMBs have come to learn over the years: customisations are risky, expensive and becomes an anchor to the past.
What is customisation?
Customization falls into six categories:
User Interface changes
Reports, documents and forms
Integration to other applications
Modification of standard functionality
Extension of functionality
While the first three items are all pretty harmless, the last three have shown to be where the problems start. Integrating with external applications and modifying or extending the functionality of the ERP system have proven to be tricky paths to walk down.
Then why do companies choose to do it anyway?
The history of ERP-systems for the SMB market
The PC revolution that started in the mid-1980’s brought information technology to the SMB market. The demand for standard software applications exploded, and as the prices came down, SMBs were fast to invest in the new productivity enhancement opportunities. Where the new shrink-wrapped software could support the same tasks across industries, the early ERP packages only had limited functionality and very limited support for industry-specific needs.
It was Navision that invented the idea of adding an SDK (Software Development Kit) to their core application allowing resellers and their customers to change and extend the functionality. For two reasons that became a huge success:
It provided a framework for accommodating the need for additional functionality.
Resellers and customers could use it themselves and therefore avoided making Navision the bottleneck for further development.
With Navigator AL (Application Language) and Concorde XAL (eXtended Application Language), Navision built a new industry where value-added resellers helped thousands of SMB customers with IT support for their business processes.
However, as time went by two lessons were learned:
Customizations are development projects. They can and sometimes do go wrong.
Customisations are tied to a specific version of the software and to the people who did them.
Companies became more reluctant to the idea of changing the software and started demanding standard solutions instead and opting for adapting their business processes to the software.
The statement “all companies are different” may be true, but management soon found out that singing that song could lead to substantial investments in software projects. “Maybe companies are not that different after all and maybe we can learn to run our processes better by changing them rather than changing the software,” became the new mantra.
The proliferation of vertical and horizontal solution
The ERP vendors and their resellers read the writing on the wall and started to develop more vertical and horizontal functionality that could be shared by more customers. What previously required customisation now became available off the shelf. But most of it was still tied to specific versions of the software, and while it was no longer the individual customer’s headache, the resellers had to recoup the investments in upgrading whenever a new core was released by the vendor.
All good things come from above
The final alternative to customisations in the core software came with the introduction of the ASP (Application Software Provider) and later SaaS (Software-as-a-Service) delivery formats. What we now know as Cloud-based solutions.
Moving the entire IT-infrastructure out of the companies and into big specialised data centres operated by the vendors offered so much value for all type of customers. The demand started at the bottom of the market, but it gradually became apparent that larger companies could also benefit.
But Saas and customisations don’t go well together (normally *). The advantage of SaaS is closely related to all customers running on the same version of the software.
Today, after the software industry has invested trillions of dollars in new architectures, we have reached a stage where configuring the standard software can accommodate most of the needs for customisation. The core software can cover more functional areas that you can turn on and off as required. It is no longer one huge monolithic system, but a suite of best-of-breed collection of applications that is designed to communicate with each other.
The competitive value proposition today
“Our competitive advantage is that we have a solid understanding of what standard functionality Dynamics 365 offers and the ability to guide our customers to a solution that requires as little customisation as possible”, says a CEO of a Microsoft reseller. “Where our competitor recommends his proprietary solution or meeting the customer’s requirement with an extension, we do the opposite. However, doing so requires that we understand both the customer’s business and Dynamics 365 intimately.”
The CEO also explains that just ten years ago 50 per cent of their staff were programmers and other technical people. Today that number is 25 per cent and declining.
“Our customers want and are prepared to pay for business consulting, where we guide them in finding the most effective way of using what’s already there,” says the CEO. “We employ civil engineers, chartered accounts and economists and invest heavily in training them in Dynamics 365. We also cover many more domains today than we did ten years ago. Our customers expect us to also help them with SCM, CRM, HR, PLM and all the other areas that need IT-support.”
While the primary competitive advantages today may be product and industry insight serving the SMB market, it also requires vertical solutions.
“SMB customers want out of the box solutions,” says an industry consultant, “so vertical solutions are in higher demand than ever. But your vertical solutions must follow the architecture prescribed by your vendor. The days of lock-in are over. The customers have learned the value of staying up to date, keeping their options open and do not want to be monopolised”
The future of ERP solutions
Improving productivity and competitiveness through the application of ERP software will still be in high demand. But companies reject the principle that just one system must cover all needs. The nature of managing your supply chain, planning your production, serving your workforce and generating customers for your business are very different. Therefore, ERP solutions move away from one monolithic system to a suite of integrated best of breed solutions.
Customers want more business process support and less hardware and software. They want the solutions delivered from the Cloud. They want to replace CAPEX (capital expenditure) with OPEX (operational expenditure) and distribute the application selection responsibility to their line managers.
These trends have profound impact on the skillset of the ERP-resellers and implementation companies.
Companies expect their ERP partner to provide inspiration and guidance on how their solutions can improve their productivity. They want business consulting.
Companies expect their ERP partner to have intimate knowledge about the solutions they are promoting and how to best apply the standard functionality to meet their specific needs. They want application consulting.
Companies expect their ERP partner to tie it all together providing transparency, improving productivity and avoiding redundancy. The want integration consulting.
There will still be a need for customer specific solutions, but the architecture will be different:
Most customization can be done by configuring the standard.
Changes and extensions will be made outside the core using APIs provided by the vendor.
Cross-company coordination will be provided by tying the applications together.
Integrating software applications was previously a complicated and expensive endeavour. Mainly because the software was not designed to be integrated, was controlled by different vendors and took uncoordinated directions of development.
With Dynamics 365, Microsoft has completely changed the playing field. They have set out to provide their resellers and implementation partners with the suite of tools they need to meet the demand from the market. Each application is designed to satisfy the specific needs of the customer’s various lines of business (business management, analytics, SCM, manufacturing, HR, marketing, sales, customer success etc.). And the applications are all prepared for integration forming a coherent and transparent business solution for the individual customer. Delivered from the Cloud and designed so customers can stay up to date and take advantage of new technology and facilities as they become available.
To win the SMB market for business software Microsoft will continue to invest heavily in Dynamics 365. And I’d say they are well positioned with a very comprehensive package and the biggest reseller network in the world. If these resellers can manage the shift from the “tell me what you want, and I can program it” mindset and become business, application and integration consultants, then I see no reason why Dynamics 365 should not grow to enjoy the same level of market share as Office 365.
*With Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central this is for sure possible though – and with less “tied hands” feeling for customers – via Extensions.
You may also find this interesting
Ready to Start – Dynamics 365 Business Central
Update on Dynamics 365 Business Central 9 May 2019
Watch here the Webinar update of the 9th of May 2019.
Customers know what they want – or do they?
Customers know what they want – or do they? […]
Interview on QBS group getting shareholder majority in 1ClickFactory
QBS GROUP TAKES THE MAJORITY OF 1CLICKFACTORY SHARES Microsoft […]
What does the latest Dynamics 365 Business Central Update (April ’19) mean for Europe, Middle East & Africa?
The April 2019 Business Central Licensing Guide has recently been released, but are there differences from the previous ones? In short, yes.
Press release: QBS group becomes majority shareholder of 1ClickFactory
Leusden, The Netherlands, April 2019 QBS group and […]
Update on Dynamics 365 Business Central 11 April 2019
This series of webinars is intended to share the […]
How to inspire your customers as an IT Business Partner?
These days, IT innovation develops faster than ever before […]
Daily reports from eXtreme 2019, Amsterdam
Our Dynamics Expert Arjen Jansen is providing daily reports […]
Update on Dynamics 365 Business Central 14 March 2019
Technical update and License update 1 April 2109
White Paper – Microsoft Dynamics 365 the perfect platform for digital transformation in the mid-market
At QBS group we’re all about Dynamics partners – […]
Business Software Consultants – a trusted advisor to customers
“I want to make people happy!” Interview with Wesley […]
Update on Dynamics 365 Business Central 7 February 2019
This series of webinars is intended to share the […]
Ready to Start Microsoft Dynamics 365 Customer Engagement
Directions EMEA 2018 Business Report
This unique report features a broad but insightful and independent business reporting on the happenings at DIRECTIONS EMEA 2018.
Microsoft Dynamics 365 – the perfect platform for new business ventures
Microsoft has thousands of business partners. Is this market not the red ocean?
Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central (On-Premise) is here! What does this mean for you as Partners?
Microsoft has just released the On-Premise Version, and this means big things in the on – premise market, as well as the existing NAV market
Ready to Go for Dynamics 365 Business Central
The new requirements for CSP Direct: Is license administration part of a Microsoft Dynamics partner’s core business?
Microsoft is changing the rules of the Cloud Solution Provider […]
Add value on top of Dynamics 365 Business Central with Extensions 2.0 knowledge!
do you stay and extend your property or do you go upmarket
Build your businesses muscle and keep fit (in the QBS gym).
Don’t worry we are not suggesting here that you […]
Dynamics 365 for Sales Acceleration Program – Reference MKB365
MKB365 has set up a separate business model for implementation […]
Highlights from eXtreme 365 EMEA 2018
Get all the highlights of eXtreme 365 EMEA 2018 and watch this 6 minutes video.
Update on Dynamics 365 Business Central
This series of webinars is intended to share the […]
13 June 2019Webinar
What can Dynamics CRM Partners expect from eXtreme365 EMEA 2018?
eXtreme 365 is the annual event for Microsoft Dynamics […]
The evolution of Dynamics 365 opens the door for new opportunities
Being a Dynamics CRM partner today is like dancing on a volcano – far from boring!
“Ever change a winning team”
“Ever change a winning team” Alex Ferguson, former football […]
Looking back at 2017
As we close our books on 2017, we start […]
But do I really need to blog?
If you want to be noticed and visible online […]
GDPR … and what now ?
Starting from 25 May 2018 there is going to be a […]
Stand and Deliver, your customers will be mine!
Upgrade your Customers NOW! Or Someone else WILL.
Position NAV as stepping stone for more Dynamics 365 ‘Tenerife’ deals
Since the introduction of the Dynamics 365 Business Edition in the US and Canada late 2016, the position of Dynamics NAV is under pressure! Competitors took the chance to position NAV as an old-fashioned solution and that’s a direct threat to your NAV business!
Exclusive interview with Jeff Edwards Director for ERP Channel Strategy Microsoft
“If you’re an ERP partner not selling CRM, and not having a focus on verticals in 2018 – I don’t know what you’re doing”
Ready to Start – Dynamics 365 Customer Engagement
Take the Lead
As a Microsoft Reseller, you are considering to collaborate […]
DIRECTIONS EMEA 2017 business report is available now!
Never before it was so important for Dynamics partners […]
Business Edition is off – long live Tenerife!
Our team is just getting back from Directions in […]
Directions EMEA 2017 in Madrid: Microsoft shares core beliefs that Dynamics SMB partners can embrace
As a longtime Microsoft-observer with a perspective geared toward […]
Our Build or Buy Agenda
When I joined QBS group a year back, it […]
Directions EMEA 2017 Madrid
Find here all the information you as Microsoft Reseller […]
Reflections on this weeks announcements from Microsoft
One of our founders summarized this week plain and […]
Slimstock and QBS group join forces to strengthen QBS partner capabilities
Leusden, 21th of September 2017 Slimstock: market leader in inventory […]
The CSP Direct model is like an iceberg
We noticed that the market is changing, our clients are, more and more, requesting a subscription based approach. This allows them to not have their own services nor the hassle.
General Data Protection Regulations (GDPR) – a Microsoft perspective
The EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) is the […]
Inspire 2017 – A look back at 11 big stories for Microsoft Dynamics Partners
As a longtime WPC / Inspire-observer with a perspective […]
What Dynamics Partners can expect from Inspire 2017
Microsoft is on the move! Ever since the start […]
7 Strong arguments to sell Dynamics NAV today
Dynamics NAV finds itself in an interesting position today! […]
Dynamics NAV Development: Extensions or Extinction?
No one wants to be a dinosaur, it does […]
Do you know your new competitors with Dynamics 365 for Financials?
The new kids-on-the-block with outsell you on Dynamics 365 […]
What is the Microsoft Cloud Solution Provider Program (Microsoft CSP)
The Microsoft Cloud Solution Provider Program (CSP) enables partners to directly manage their entire Microsoft cloud customer lifecycle.
Dynamics 365 Business Edition: Opportunity or Threat
Microsoft will be launching Dynamics 365 Business Edition in […]
Get yourself a niche, in order to be successful
At QBS group we believe that our partners deserve […]
“Our alliance with QBS group has been very important in the development of our business strategy.”
In Sofkia we know that there are not two […]
VS Sistemas “QBS group helps us build our road to success.”
The strategy of VS Sistemas is to improve its […]
C2IT Business Solutions about QBS group
C2IT Business Solutions is a part of C2IT A/S. […]
As an ISV your first focus is developing and […]
After Directions EMEA 2016, Microsoft Dynamics NAV partners face crucial decisions on their future
As a longtime Microsoft-observer with a perspective geared toward […]
QBS group helps you to really understand CSP!
The new Cloud Solution Provider (CSP) program is going […]
Making winners out of users
Do you want to bring more value to your […]
WPC 2016 Notebook: A look back at 11 big stories for Microsoft Dynamics partners
As a longtime WPC-observer with a perspective geared toward […]
What is the Microsoft CSP Program?
In order to be successful in a Cloud first, […]
The fact that we belong to a larger organisation gives our customers security.
Verito delivers Microsoft Dynamics NAV to charity organisations and […]
Adfocom “Partner Care saved us a lot of time.”
Adfocom is an IT service provider based in Alphen […]
NavAzure: “We are a small company with a great organisational support base”
NavAzure is a newly established company, which currently one […]
Make Money Using ISV Solutions
Nowadays, as a Microsoft Dynamics partner you can’t do […]
Without the help from QBS group we wouldn’t have succeeded.
Blisss is a Dutch reseller of Microsoft Dynamics NAV. […]
Creative Ways of Dealing with Your Capacity Problem
A lot of Microsoft Dynamics partners are dealing with […]
How to survive Mobilegeddon?
On the 21st of April 2015, Google released a […]
What people say about QBS Group
Owner en Co-founder at MKB365
Since the start of our company 4 months ago, we have already completed 12 Dynamics 365 for Sales implementations.